The first night Milo slept in the crib instead of the bassinet beside our bed, I sat on the nursery floor at 2:14 in the morning and listened to him breathe through a monitor speaker. He was about six months old. At birth he was seven pounds six ounces, and by mid August he was a completely different person. The bassinet had been close enough to touch. The crib was across the hall, and I had badly underestimated how far away seven feet of hallway can feel.
The hard part was not the crib. It was that every night looked different. Some nights Nate put him down. Some nights I did. One of us would rock him longer than the other, and the room had no signal in it that meant this is bedtime, this is bedtime, this is bedtime. The Hatch Baby was already sitting on the dresser by then. It had been on nap duty since Milo was about six weeks old, and I had never once thought to switch it on at night.
Those first two weeks in the nursery were rough. Twenty minute stretches, a baby who went down fine and then startled himself awake at the top of every sleep cycle. I tried the obvious things. I moved the video monitor closer. I stood in the doorway. I read a great many forum threads at three in the morning, which is not a plan, it is a symptom. What I actually needed was for the room to feel like the same room every single night, no matter who put him down or how tired either of us was.
So I built one routine on the Hatch Baby and I have not changed it since. Feed. One book, always the same board book, which I can now recite from memory. The light on the dresser dims to a warm glow. Pink Noise comes on low. He goes down awake, on his back, on a firm flat mattress with nothing else in the crib. That is the entire routine. It sounds too small to matter and I understand why it reads that way. What made it work for us is that it is identical, in the same order, with the same sounds, every time.
Here is what the thing actually is, because I think this gets glossed over. The Hatch Baby is corded, about four inches square and six and a half inches tall, and it has never moved off that dresser. Everything else is set up in the Hatch Sleep app, which needs Wi-Fi. That is the part I like least. I do not love needing my phone to adjust a nursery. There is a big button on top to start, pause or stop, and you turn it to change the volume, so at two in the morning I can do it by feel in the dark without opening anything.
The routine did not make him sleep. It made the room predictable, and predictable turned out to be the only part I could actually control.
The same sound, the same light, the same order, every single night
Pink Noise, Heartbeat and a dimmable warm light, scheduled in the app so the room does the same thing every night even when you are running on nothing. Check today's price on Amazon.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →
The light did more than I expected. When the room went warm and low, my shoulders came down before Milo's did, which is its own kind of useful at 7 p.m. on a Tuesday. The machine still does not make him sleep. The first week of the new routine he still woke at 11 and 3 and 5, and I still walked across the hall each time. Milo is nine months old and he still wakes some nights. Some weeks are better than others and I have stopped keeping score.
Two other things, because I promised myself I would be straight about this one. First, the Hatch Baby stays home. It is corded and there is no battery, so it does not come on trips, and on our one weekend away to my mother's in Erie we took the monitor and the blackout blind and left this on the dresser. Second, I have never owned a basic white noise machine, so I cannot tell you from experience how it compares. From the listings I have read, a plain machine costs less, needs no app, and would probably do the core job. If all you want is noise, that is a reasonable way to go.
What keeps it on my dresser is the routine and the light together, not the sound on its own. A plain machine does not hold a schedule and does not dim. That is what I bought it for. The Hatch+ trial ran out after three months, it does not renew on its own, I let it end, and I have not paid anything since. I do not miss it. I unplugged the whole unit once to dust the dresser and the room felt wrong all evening.
What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table
If you were across from me with a mug and a nine month old at home, I would tell you a few things. The piece that helped most in our house came first, and it was not a device, it was the order of the steps. Sound and light only made the steps repeatable. I would set the routine up in the app on a Sunday afternoon when you are not already exhausted, not at bedtime on a Wednesday. I would not expect it to stop night waking, because it did not, and I would watch where the cord runs so nothing is within reach of the crib. And if money is tight, a plain white noise machine and a dim lamp are a fair place to start. The Hatch Baby is a nice thing to have. It is not the reason a baby sleeps.
If you want the whole routine in one place, this is where I would start
Pink Noise, Heartbeat, a dimming warm light and a schedule that runs itself, in a corded unit that sits on the dresser and stays there. Check today's price on Amazon.
Amazon See the Hatch Baby on Amazon →